5 Easy Pet Insurance Tips That Actually Save You Money

🔎 Disclosure: Heads up, babe: some links here are affiliate links, which means you might throw a tiny commission my way if you buy (zero extra cost to you). Only things you’d actually use and love get shared on this site.

1. Avoid Paying for Extra Coverage You Don’t Need

Pet insurance can feel like ordering cable. Suddenly, you’re paying for channels (or coverages) you’ll never use.

Stick with the basics and avoid the unnecessary fluff they sneak into the fine print.

Here’s what you should focus on instead:

  • Essential coverage only. Pick accident and illness coverage. Skip rare add-ons like travel or dental cleanings.
  • Read every clause. Companies love hiding small things that cost big later.
  • Compare coverage types. See if you’re paying for things already included under a general plan.
👉 Here's How You'll Do It: Review your current policy and cancel any optional add-ons that don’t match your pet’s real risks.

Make It Easy: Use Insurify to compare pet insurance plans side by side before locking into one.


2. Higher Deductibles Mean Lower Monthly Payments

Want smaller monthly premiums? Raise that deductible, friend.

You’ll save monthly, but just make sure you can actually afford the higher out-of-pocket if an emergency happens.

Here’s how to balance it out:

  • Pick your sweet spot. A $500–$1,000 deductible can cut your monthly bill by 20–40%.
  • Avoid super-high ones. Saving $15 a month isn’t worth a $2,000 shock later.
  • Build a cushion. Keep your deductible amount tucked in savings just in case.
👉 Here's How You'll Do It: Choose a deductible you could realistically cover from savings without using credit.

Make It Easy: Use a Betterment Cash Reserve Account to stash away your pet emergency fund automatically.


3. Paying Out-of-Pocket for Small Treatments Saves More

Here’s a secret most people don’t realize. Filing small claims can raise your premiums later.

It’s often cheaper to just handle those minor vet visits yourself.

Think about it like this:

  • Skip the $75 claims. Save insurance for big surgeries or emergencies.
  • Keep a “pet fund.” A mini savings pot for small stuff keeps premiums lower long-term.
  • Track your receipts. You’ll see patterns in small costs you can plan for yearly.
👉 Here's How You'll Do It: Pay vet bills under $200 out-of-pocket and reserve insurance for the major ones.

Make It Easy: Consider a pet expense log book to record all your vet visits and treatments.


4. Preventive Care Helps You Avoid Expensive Bills

A little prevention now saves you hundreds (sometimes thousands) later.

Simple checkups and vaccines can stop major illnesses before they even start.

Here’s how to make preventive care your wallet’s best friend:

  • Stick to checkups. Annual vet visits keep hidden problems from becoming five-figure emergencies.
  • Stay on vaccines. Preventable diseases cost far more than a booster shot.
  • Brush those teeth. Dental problems are sneaky. And very expensive to fix.
👉 Here's How You'll Do It: Book regular vet checkups and make preventive care part of your annual budget.

Make It Easy: Consider an electric pet toothbrush kit to prevent pricey dental cleanings.


5. Pet Insurance Prices Go Up as Pets Age

The older your furry bestie gets, the pricier the insurance becomes.

Locking in coverage while your pet is young saves you serious cash later.

Keep this in mind before waiting too long:

  • Enroll early. Younger pets = lower rates that last for years.
  • Avoid “late starts.” Older pets come with more exclusions and higher premiums.
  • Don’t switch plans. Changing insurers later often resets waiting periods and removes coverage for preexisting issues.
👉 Here's How You'll Do It: Get your pet insured as early as possible and stick with one consistent provider.

Make It Easy: Consider a digital pet record organizer to keep vaccination and policy info in one spot.


📌 SAVE IT FOR LATER! 📌


Photo of author

Lily Thompson

Hey, I'm Lily! I'm a mom who's really good at two things: stretching a dollar and talking about stretching a dollar. I created Money Vice after one too many grocery trips where I watched my total climb and thought, "There's gotta be a better way." Spoiler: there is. Think of me as your money-savvy friend who's always got a tip (and coffee in hand).